Hanover replies to PMs
Page 1 of 6133 12311 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 327

Thread: Hanover replies to PMs

  1. #1
    As PMs don't allow attachments, I'll reply to them in this thread. OK, here is the first one....

    No, I've never coded a MTF CCI, however I discovered the attached indy in my archives. You may also look to the Project Ultra thread, and ask jmw1970 if he's coded one. Also maybe check http://www.forex-tsd.com/indiors-met...r-indiors.html, and try Googling something such as mtf cci mt4 if you haven't previously done so. Https://www.nigeriaforextrading.com/...2993278023.mq4_________________

    Personal contact

    Sorry, but I'm not longer accepting personal messages, and I won't be responding to any FX associated e-mails. However:

    #61623; In case you're looking for MT4 programming, please visit the 'MT4 programming' section below.
    #61623; Should you wish to ask about profitable EAs, sorry, but I don't know of some that are publicly available.
    #61623; Should you want trading information, I'm only a part-time amateur, but if you want my opinions, see the 'Strategy tips...' section below.
    #61623; If you want proof that it is possible to be always profitable at FX, visit this.


    Strategy tips, thoughts and caveats

    Please remember that, although I've been playing the markets since 2001, I'm a retired programmer, not a pro trader. I run a couple of small accounts as a hobby, and I love tinkering with both automated and optional approaches. All of the following is offered on a basis. I recommend that you take nothing for granted test the viability of concepts and egies for your own satisfaction over several months' worth of altering markets -- before using them on a live account.

    #61623; FWIW here's the basis of my approach, which uses a lot of FA. For folk who favor TA, and would like some original ideas as a potential starting point to research further, you may like to try out this (mostly mean reversion; again here), or this (trend following; see that the past couple of paragraphs).

    #61623; As asked by MTaufiq, I've also shared some ideas on trading myths, the market 'iceberg', orderflow patterns, automated methods, approaches and markets, money management, constraints of TA, qualitative analysis, nuanced analysis, visibility, statistical validity, scaling up yields, martingale (and here), expectancy and MM, retrieval trading, risk calculations, risk of ruin, standing sizing, P/L considerations, pyramiding, inverting losses, nedging (and here), randomness (and here), uncorrelated rankings, indior kinds, price-following indiors, strength meters, repainting, Bollinger bands, overbought/sold, sacred grail, STP/ECN/NDD brokers, eduors, vendors, naysayers (and here), developers, programming asks (and here), member rankings, trade explorers, competitions, losing transactions, trading 'pyramid', seven columns, KISS, Ryan Jones MM, Gil Blake, plogy, gambler's fallacy (and here), Newcomb's paradox, roulette and MONOPOLY.

    #61623; Among my favorite posts on ace trading are by fx1986, Ziad (blue typeface ), , TheRealThing, Gaston, topherhk88, and Parmalat.

    #61623; Perhaps the most important post I've read in my 12 years atnigeriaforextradingwas composed by alphaomega (IMHO anybody who doesn't understand its impliions should not ever try to exchange).

    #61623; here's a great video on the realities of trading with prop trader Tom Dante (warning: he utilizes a few colorful language!) . Tom's YouTube channel is https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT4...tx7i903Yxcwxjw.

    #61623; Outstanding audio podcasts using REAL pro traders https://chatwithtraders.com/podcast-episodes/.

    #61623; FWIW the extent of what I'd learned up to 2012 is reflected in this informative article, which also includes links to a lot of my old posts.

    #61623; Eduing tips: MT4 navigation tips, using iCustom(). (see also 'Miscellaneous resources' section below)

    #61623; The brain teasers thread -- heaps of seriously excellent puzzles led by variousnigeriaforextradingmembers -- if you have enough time to kill waiting for your market.

    I shall add to the list as I find other great (IMHO) links or posts. Anybody, please feel welcome to post suggestions.


    MT4 programming

    I am quite sorry, but I'm no longer coding or troubleshooting indiors or EAs, neither for repayment nor goodwill. (Reasons and here).

    #61623; You may try posting in one of those I code your indiors for free stickers (e.g. here), and hopefully someone can help you.

    #61623; In case you need an indior, you could look in this thread (note especially the posts here and here, where you'll find ZIP files containing thousands of indiors), the links in the 'Miscellaneous resources' and 'MT4 Indiors' segments below, or try finding it with Google. It will have to be compiled with MetaEditor/compiler build 509 -- view this, if a MQ4 document was composed prior to Feb 2014.

    #61623; In case you want to attempt and build an EA yourself, you could try out any one of https://fxdreema.com/, http://www.eatree.com/index-1.html, https://forexsb.com/, or http://www.molanis.com/. Search YouTube for videos showing how to use them. As I've never used any of these myself I can not offer a recommendation.

    #61623; If you are willing to pay to get a programmer do the work, you could try https://www.mql5.com/en/job or even https://www.upwork.com/o/profiles/br...l4-programming. There are many developers who are pleased to code for cash. Or should you would rather stay within the boundaries of FF, then there are many competent developers you could try calling, e.g. http://www.ervent.net/, http://cjatradingtools.com/, https://www.upwork.com/fl/stephenambatoding, http://wiseea.wix.com/wise-ea#!contact, mladen, Nicholishen, pips4life, , Xaphod, cyber1, euclid, futurespec, MathTrader7, , ....

    #61623; In case you want to teach yourself MQL4 programming, Jim Dandy has generated some very good tutorials (e.g. https://www.jimdandymql4courses.com/ https://www.jimdandyforex.com/ or https://www.youtube.com/playlist?lis...ejAJnqc_RIKLU5).


    Miscellaneous resources

    Some other great sources for MT4 indiors (apart from FF's search center):Https://www.nigeriaforextrading.com/...t-advisor.html (see ZIP file attached to post #1) http://codebase.mql4.com/ (peform a website search) http://www.forexmt4.com/_MT4_Indiors/ http://www.greattradingsystems.com/f...der-4-indiors/ http://www.desynced.net/fx/eas/indiors.php https://www.best-metatrader-indiors.com/ https://www.forexmt4indiors.com/forex-mt4-indiors/ http://www.dolphintrader.com/metatrader4-indiors/ http://forex-indiors.net/mt4-indiors https://mt4indiors.com/ Other material:Links. MT4 navigational egies and techniques here. List of more than 200 MT4 br0kers http://www.100forexbrokers.com/mt4forexbrokers. The way to compile old (made before Feb 2014) MQ4 records here. Equity curve simulators http://www.equitycurvesimulator.com/ and http://swaytheworld.com/equityCurveSim.html.
    MT4 Indiors

    Here's an alphabetical list of some of those MT4 indiors and EAs that I've written (links are on the newest versions, so far as I know):

    #61623; Action FX signals
    #61623; Candle lengths
    #61623; Candle strength
    #61623; Chiming clock (this is an executable app, not an indior)
    #61623; Claudia's wine bar EA (this is an EA, not an indior)
    #61623; Close/delete orders (this is an EA, not an indior)
    #61623; CME options amounts
    #61623; Crucial amounts
    #61623; CSM (currency strength meter)
    #61623; Currency strength - Giraia
    #61623; Daily high/low histogram
    #61623; Daily lines/boxes
    #61623; Display info all pairs
    #61623; EMA dashboard (newest .ex4 variants for Stochastic, RSI, EMA and Oscillator dashboards here)
    #61623; Find unmatched parentheses (this is an executable app, not an indior)
    #61623; Guppy CBL and GMMA (latest fix to Guppy CBL here)
    #61623; J4D strength
    #61623; Load price history (this is an executable app, not an indior)
    #61623; MA dashboard
    #61623; MACD conventional
    #61623; MTF supply/demand zones (using Bredin's 'II_SupDem' method)
    #61623; Options levels
    #61623; Output background and script (instructions)
    #61623; Pair Strength Analyzer (PSA) (usage info here, here and here; just how RefreshPeriod works)
    #61623; Plot COT futures
    #61623; Plot external information (example)
    #61623; https://www.nigeriaforextrading.com/...n-trading.html (related links; history/usage; the way to extractnigeriaforextradingcalendar data)
    #61623; Recent Candles
    #61623; Recent Prices
    #61623; Recent S/R
    #61623; Recent Strength (links to additional strength meters in green typeface ; greatest strength indy)
    #61623; Room up/down
    #61623; Screenshot EA (this is an EA, not an indior)
    #61623; Sessions/time zones (more info)
    #61623; Signal indior
    #61623; https://www.nigeriaforextrading.com/...d-raschke.html (more info)
    #61623; Stochastic dashboard (newest .ex4 variants for Stochastic, RSI, EMA and Oscillator dashboards here)
    #61623; System info dump (this is a script, not a indior)
    #61623; Time zones (newest links)
    #61623; Trades History
    #61623; Trend length count
    #61623; Unscramble binary files (this can be a script, not a indior)

    #61623; Indiors must be downloaded in your .../MQL4/Indiors folder.
    #61623; EAs must be downloaded in your .../MQL4/Experts folder.
    #61623; Scripts must be downloaded in your .../MQL4/Scripts folder.
    #61623; Documents should be downloaded in your .../MQL4/Files folder.
    Utilize the File....Open Data Folder.... Choice on the menu that is MT4 to find your folder that is MQL4.
    After installing the .ex4 file, open MT4's Navigator (type Ctrl-N) and then right click and click on 'Refresh' to update the Navigator's expandable 'trees' with all the new indior/EA/script.

    Requirements and conditions:

    #61623; I've written these indiors and progr originally and primarily for my own use. All code is supplied at no cost, and is offered on an 'as is' basis. I'm NOT offering a programming or troubleshooting service. Where source code is supplied, you're welcome to alter it** for your own use; however, neither the first nor altered versions may be sold or distributed commercially.

    #61623; I offer no guarantee that the software is appropriate for purpose, or free of errors. Download and use the indior(s) in your own risk. I take no liability for losses or personal harm.

    [**NOTE: all these indiors were written using MetaEditor/compiler construct 509, as well as the code libraries. In case the .mq4 origin is available, and you would like it to compile/run without errors, you'll need to do this first. Otherwise, download only the .ex4 file]


    F.A.Q.

    I received a Few PMs asking me about my Ignore list. The majority of these folk are there because they support software piracy, or have shown disrespect toward programmers' work; and to stop me their requests are now automatically hidden from me.

    I also receive a lot of PMs asking me about which would be the most profitable EAs, or to get overall trading advice. That's flattering, since I'm a programmer, NOT a professional forex trader. Nonetheless, I enjoy tinkering with systems and run a few small accounts. I'd like to play with blackjack, and I think in the inviolability of expectancy math; many of my opinions are grounded in Math 101, commonsense logic, and a fundamental understanding of how markets operate.

    Anyhow, for whatever it is worth, here is my response to a single PM that I received. The author asked me about how he can make a living from conducting EAs (he said something like I'm not looking for the holy grail, only an EA with a 60% win rate):

    When there was an easy means of attaining a guaranteed consistent 60% win rate, we would be forex millionaires. Any platform that#8217;s certain to deliver any kind of profit (assuming such a system exists) IS THE HOLY GRAIL. The key word being8220;guaranteed";.

    Read this post, which was written by Joel Rensink, that has been trading forex for more than 30 years. Also this one. Then understand that these men are specialist traders, and that experienced traders will consistently outperform EAs. EAs can't apply smart 'contextual' analysis or conform to changing market conditions. As the expression goes a good trader follows his principles; a fantastic trader knows when to break them.

    As an instance, the EAs that I co-developed here have backtested very profitably (up to 20% return per year), but that provides no guarantee that they'll be profitable going forward on a live account. And even in backtest, they don't generate returns that are consistent -- there are shedding months. After 7 years of studying forex, this really is the very best that I have been able to realize. Please read the posts by mim2005 in that thread, in which he speaks about automated forex systems being a small (and the most risky) part of a balanced investment portfolio.

    Http://grailtrading.blogspot.co.nz/ is an interesting blog written by some very experienced traders. Read their EA, that was doing than ours, crashed as it suddenly encountered market conditions that the programmers hadn't expected.

    The only way to learn forex would be to begin reading and experimenting yourself. If you would like to be profitable, be prepared for a long trip (I'm in my tenth year now and I'm still studying). There are not any tricks, and no shortcuts. There is not any return without taking a quantity of risk. In general, if you would like yields, then you must take risks, which means drawdowns your egy encounters market conditions. IMO you ought to trade only that you could afford to lose.

    If forex is the only source of earnings, then there'll be added pressure to satisfy the goals needed to cover your bills. If losses permit you to get behind in meeting your goals, you'll discover yourself needing into overtrading, which eventually leads to errors and bigger losses.


    Now that we've got the caveats out of the way, here are a few (free)nigeriaforextradingthreads that have helped me to understand forex:

    James16 is highly regarded, although his price action techniques tend to function best on longer timeframes. At any rate, it is a good introduction to knowing candles and support/resistance kinds.

    Millipede is a great concept, that entails taking low risk intraday entries, an then enabling those that hold to play over many days/weeks/months, for high RR trades.

    Deadly accuracy also gives low risk intraday entries, around probable change points.

    No-brainer trades utilizes support/resistance to do similarly.

    Seneca pilot's Ramblings explains key amounts that are recognized by institutional traders.

    Money flows, but not specifically a platform, provides exceptional material that every trader must know.

    If You Want indior-based systems, here are some of the very popular ones:
    Sonic R
    Genesis
    Choros
    Trading Made Easy
    Trade What You Watch
    symphonie
    To be fair, I harbor#8217;t followed any of them extensively, however they have been around for Some Time, and I#8217;t read great things about these.

    IMO, items to remain well away from: anything between Martingale versions, adding to losing trades, broad or no stoplosses, recovery-type systems. More info here. A lot of these concepts can work profitably for many months, providing the trader a false sense of success, before they crash spectacularly. Among the reasons that many traders lose, is that they make conclusions based on their, rather than market behavior and probabilities.

    In addition to the above, and should you would like to trade successfully intraday, find out as much as possible (Google, YouTube) about those concepts:

    -- Orderflow trading (check out posts by skfx in this thread).
    -- How banks control forex markets (and sabotage retail traders). Look for videos that are YouTube by people like Mark Chapman and Martin Cole.
    -- Sam Seiden supply and demand levels (there's also a thorough post here).

    It's my view that many robust systems are based around price patterns and behavior created by underlying drivers such as: macroeconomics, money flows, levels of supply and demand, orderflow, the need to maintain across-the-board triangular equilibrium (e.g. EURJPY = EURUSD x USDJPY), breakouts through times of liquidity, monitoring central bank/heavyweight activity, self-fulfilling prophecy, news trading, and evaporating extreme overboughtness/oversoldness, trapped trader behavior, crucial OHLC and 'bank' amounts, session/time-of-day idiosyncrasies.... And no doubt many others that I'm unaware of. Conventional indiors don't directly measure any of them. With all of these factors acting continuously and simultaneously, forex is perhaps the most complex market to analyze and commerce.

    The strongest approach that I currently know of entails studying price from the perspective of longer term trend power, and then the manner in that it consolidates, then expands, then consolidates, then expands, over and above, within the tendency.

    I've been around Forex mill's forum for at least 11 years now. Here is a listing of contributors (past or current) whom I think are either profitable traders, or have helped to shape the way that I consider forex. IMO there is high quality information in their posts:

    alphaomega, , , BetterLife, , billflet, BillyRayVal, birdt, capitalist88, , , copi88, Craig, CrucialPoint, Cubbybgood, , Darkstar, , daytrading, Dopey, endroute, FerruFX, flotsom, forexhard, , , FXEZ, Gaston, grkfx, , HedgePiglet, Houdini, ianf0ster, Igrok, , Jack_Larkin, , Jarroo, , , kiwi_trader, kprsa, MagnumFreak, , , , mikkom, mim2005, mypipbull, nhen, , numbnuts, Parmalat, PeterCrowns, PeterFM, philmcgrew, pipEASY, PipMeUp, , Porkpie, Rabid, , Seneca_pilot, Sis.yphus, , skenobi, skfx, , soultrader, , the_wizard, TheRealThing, TeamAphid, topherhk88, triphop, Trotty, ubeee, unknown4x, vox_dei, wmd

    No doubt there are other traders That Are equally worthy of honorable mention, howevernigeriaforextradingis a Huge forum, and there are not enough hours in a day to see, let alone test, every Idea that's presented here.

    A number of the eduional stuff I have listed comprises a commercial schedule. Play your own due diligence, and # 8212; that option if you decide to spend money. Markets can change as they react to different economic climates and agendas, hence there is no guarantee that ANY egy will remain always profitable forever.

    However, there might well be Foreign Exchange traders who have found a an infallible price pattern that provides a handsome, constant weekly profit. Hence they would disagree with much of what I have said. It's also possible that their 'edge' might stay effective over many years worth of changing markets, and even employ a MM. If you're lucky enough to find one of those who posts 8212; follow them, and obviously # 8212; ignore what I have mentioned. But rest assured that I'm not among them.

    My 2c, for whatever it's worth,
    David

  2. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    great thread dead you can again it is restart ?
    But how?

    Nobody can induce others to take an interest in something which otherwise wouldn't interest them.

    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    pls u can it has problem repaired more enhance talk with our
    I don't understand how your system functions, hence I don't have any idea how to enhance it.

    The green/red shaded indiors on your final screenshot seem like they may work well enough in a trending market. But a lot of different progr do.

  3. #3
    If I buy 0.01 lot, then will Cease loss near leverage 1:50 and 1:200 in the same price with -5? . It won't close 1:200 faster than 1:50? Its different margin used?


    Thanks for the response and have a nice day.

  4. #4
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Some harsh reality.... There's very little point asserting that it is possible to be systematically profitable in the forex, especially in threads like this.
    Awesome post H :-)

  5. #5
    On the subject of SL vs no-SL, here8217;s a fantastic illuion of the way that it#8217;s possible to use SLs aggressively to minimize risk while trying to optimize profit. I overlooked this installment because I was at work earlier today.

    AUDJPY is currently 1 pair of option since it#8217;therefore at a sound, clean downtrend (see screenshot #1) that is also reflected in the H4/D1/W1 strength meters (JPY is consistently strong; AUD is always weak).

    Down to the M15 to time that the entrance (screenshot #2). Multiple shirts around space #8216;A#8217; plus climax volume candle (CVC) high at #8216;B8217; provide fair resistance. #8216;C#8217; is another CVC within precisely the place. Entry around candle highs, and SL maybe 2-3 pips spread above C#8217;s large. AUD monetary policy seconds triggers CVC #8216;D#8217;, triggering entrance.

    SL would currently be at BE with commerce yield currently ~5:1 RR. If long term downtrend continues within the upcoming few days, without retracement to BE, this could easily develop into a gt;20:1 RR commerce (especially as it seems to be breaking the barrier of triple bottom round number 83.00). This (low risk entry #8212;gt;gt; infinite yield) is similar to the millipede theory that was being recommended by lyondegreat before in the thread. A fantastic understanding of how to exploit appropriate S/R confluences can result in some deadly accurate entries (see this thread for more ideas).

    [EDIT] If the 83.00 level is broken, we've got another possibly perfect installation, with 3 CVCs earlier daily low (brown line) round variety 83.00 (dashed blue line) S1 pivot level (dotted grey line) all within 6 pips of one another, i.e. earlier service becomes resistance. Let us see how it stands out.


  6. #6
    As we can see from the screenshot, price has shrunk significantly since the period of the previous article, illuing beautifully the pros and cons of the use of SLs.

    By using a SL, I was stopped out at breakeven. (My rule is to maneuver the SL to BE when price hits on the other side of the Donchian (gray) channel #8212; then no further after that). Hence my net result for the transaction is 0 pips. The trade gave me the opportunity for very large yield (I might have taken 5:1 RR, but decided to leave the complete position open, with greatest room to maneuver, in the hope of making gt; 20:1).

    If I hadn't employed a SL, I would currently be at about -70 pips, using approx 50/50 probability of the drawdown worsening.

    I understand which of those two scenarios I prefer.

  7. #7
    Hanover,

    are those arrows made by the TDI and stochastic indiors?Thank you.

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Hanover,

    are those arrows made by the TDI and stochastic indiors?Thank you.
    Hi,

    No, they're actually generated with a 'candle identifier' indy that I originally posted on FF, but has subsequently been removed from the public domain because it's now being marketed as a member of some other trader's coaching course.

    Not sure why I left them on the chart, as they don't actually figure in my trading choices.

    David

  9. #9
    Dear Mr Hanover. Long time ago You helped me with indior. Would like to ask you if there is chance to see 4h and 5m RSI on a 15m chart? Or possibly indior that I can set time period that is different from what is my current chart? Thank you, Greg Shub. My email is

  10. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Dear Mr Hanover. Long time ago I was assisted by You with indior. Would love to ask you if there is chance to see 5m and 4h RSI on a 15m chart? Or possibly indior which I can set different time frame from what is my current chart? Thank you, Greg Shub. My email is
    Hi Greg,

    You can try the Project Ultra RSI here. It's intended to plot RSI on chart timeframes. I assume that it works.

    I have also attached a ZIP of MTF indiors to this article. From memory I believe you will find just one or 2 RSIs one of them.

    David
    https://www.nigeriaforextrading.com/...1079460163.zip

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to store session information to facilitate remembering your login information, to allow you to save website preferences, to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.